https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/api.php?action=feedcontributions&feedformat=atom&user=0000-0003-4410-2108 2026-04-15T03:03:59Z User contributions MediaWiki 1.35.11 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:7d5f74cd-c581-456f-8d1e-508a90bda3ac&diff=6434 2021-04-27T20:15:59Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=fabrication and falsification |Is About=Two graduate students co-author an article. After submission, they receive a response from a ref...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=fabrication and falsification<br /> |Is About=Two graduate students co-author an article. After submission, they receive a response from a referee with critical but valid comments on one section. One of the graduate students takes the lead in the revision. The other student recognizes that in the new version, the other student has changed some data, writing to the referee that they were mistakes. <br /> <br /> The graduate student is suspicious because there is no good explanation for the change of data. In addition, she knows the revising student is desperate to publish in a good journal before she starts her job search next year. <br /> <br /> However there is no concrete evidence of misconduct.<br /> |Important For=Graduate and postgraduate students; Researchers; Journal editors<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/publication/fabrication.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty; Reliability<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Fabrication; Falsification<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:Cd790a6e-0888-438a-9e2e-90feada61112&diff=6433 2021-04-27T20:14:02Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Peer review |Is About=A professor tells a student that he is peer-reviewing the article of another research group, with whom you are in...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Peer review<br /> |Is About=A professor tells a student that he is peer-reviewing the article of another research group, with whom you are in direct competition for funding. <br /> <br /> The student recognizes the conflict on interest at play. The professor asks the student for his opinion on the paper, which the student reads. The student sees that the professor is reviewing the article &quot;unfavourably&quot;, but thinks the professor has plausibly argued in the review.<br /> |Important For=All stakeholders in research<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/publication/peer-review.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Conflict of Interest<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:7ad031df-4e79-41fd-a02a-1958adf5f29d&diff=6432 2021-04-27T20:12:29Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Publication and data ownership |Is About=A student is working with his co-students and his professor on an experiment. The student becom...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Publication and data ownership<br /> |Is About=A student is working with his co-students and his professor on an experiment. The student becomes impatient with the checks the professor want to do to make sure everything is correct. He writes and submits a manuscript on their joint work with himself as first author and the other students and the professor as co-author, unbeknownst to the authors. The editor of the journal becomes suspicious due to the writing style and the fact that the professor is not included in the email, and calls the professor.<br /> |Important For=Collaborating researchers; Graduate and postgraduate students; Professors; Journal editors<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/publication/data-ownership.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Authorship; Shady practices<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:475420fa-d28a-47c6-9763-8a98a5cd9caf&diff=6431 2021-04-27T20:09:40Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Credit for work |Is About=A student, a post-doc and a professor are working on a problem. They achieve good results in their research. W...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Credit for work<br /> |Is About=A student, a post-doc and a professor are working on a problem. They achieve good results in their research. When the student is finishing his master thesis, he discovers that the professor and his post-docs have published a paper on the experiment, that he designed an important part of. He is not given any credit in the paper.<br /> |Important For=Graduate and postgraduate students; Advisors of students<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/publication/credit.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty; Reliability<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Failure of Acknowledgment<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:1e811839-d7ed-4f35-95c6-d517b6f610f1&diff=6430 2021-04-27T20:07:18Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Honest refereeing |Is About=An author sends his manuscript to be submitted for review. The referee, who gives a positive review, claims...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Honest refereeing<br /> |Is About=An author sends his manuscript to be submitted for review. The referee, who gives a positive review, claims he was coincidentally working on the same problem, and weeks later submits his own paper on the subject. The author complains about this to the editor, who calls the referee. The referee is vague and capricious in his answers.<br /> |Important For=Researchers; Referees; Journal editors<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/publication/refereeing.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty; Respect<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Shady practices; Publication Ethics; Plagiarism<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:6de042d8-4588-4514-93da-fc9f094dcded&diff=6429 2021-04-27T20:04:53Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Long distance collaboration |Is About=Two research groups are collaborating remotely. One will provide the experimental results, the oth...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Long distance collaboration<br /> |Is About=Two research groups are collaborating remotely. One will provide the experimental results, the other will provide simulations. <br /> <br /> One of the scientists from the simulating group discovers the other group has overlooked some fundamental physics. She decides this needs to be published immediately, and overnight writes a paper to demonstrate this, including experiments from their collaborators. The scientist who writes the article makes himself the first author. <br /> <br /> He sends the draft to the collaborating group, who immediately respond angrily. They reject the idea that someone else could be first author with their experiments and they threaten to cancel the collaboration, retracting all funding.<br /> |Important For=collaborating groups; Researchers<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/publication/collaboration-authorship.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Reliability<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:4db87515-f3b5-4f60-a84b-02a9815cc0ac&diff=6428 2021-04-27T20:03:01Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Collaboration dispute |Is About=A group of three scientists fails to agree on the interpretation of their findings. One of the three dec...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Collaboration dispute<br /> |Is About=A group of three scientists fails to agree on the interpretation of their findings. One of the three decides to publish separately, the other two decide to wait for the first researcher's article to be published. <br /> <br /> During the course of the project, the first researcher who is in the midst of the publication process, leaves the university. By accident, a fax from the publishing journal is sent to the old university, so the other two scientists discover where the first scientists intends to publish. They contact the journal, argue the first scientists interpretation is wrong and offer the journal their alternative view.<br /> |Important For=Academic staff; Journal editors; Journal publishers; co-working researchers<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/publication/collaboration.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty; Respect<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Shady practices<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:8dee2d88-0ff0-4723-9b06-5d64d79ccc55&diff=6427 2021-04-27T20:00:06Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Errata |Is About=A research group publishes several papers on an important finding in high-impact journals. Months later, a new graduate...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Errata<br /> |Is About=A research group publishes several papers on an important finding in high-impact journals. Months later, a new graduate student is asked to replicate this research and reproduce the findings. <br /> <br /> The student finds he is unable to reproduce the findings, and even has an explanation for this impossibility.<br /> |Important For=Graduate and postgraduate students; Researchers<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/publication/errata.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty; Accountability<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Falsification<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:1fb15e96-42ce-4976-9647-24fc0031f3d9&diff=6426 2021-04-27T19:58:20Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Dual submissions |Is About=A PhD student has excellent research results in a collaborative setting. Upon request of her supervisor, she...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Dual submissions<br /> |Is About=A PhD student has excellent research results in a collaborative setting. Upon request of her supervisor, she submits their research for publication as the submitting author. <br /> <br /> After a few weeks, the supervisor approaches the student and suggests to submit the manuscript at another journal where the submission process will be easier. The supervisor suggests they could always retract one of the two submissions if it were to be doubly accepted.<br /> |Important For=Graduate and postgraduate students; Supervisors; Referees; Academic staff<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/publication/dual-submissions.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Reliability; Honesty<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Shady practices<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:E75a85a9-e6bc-4f67-9dd4-2e117456ec38&diff=6425 2021-04-27T19:56:11Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Mentoring: disabilities |Is About=A mentor has a research student for his research group. Over the course of the semester, the student b...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Mentoring: disabilities<br /> |Is About=A mentor has a research student for his research group. Over the course of the semester, the student becomes seriously ill with a chronic disease. As a result, the student regularly misses experiments and falls behind on the research. <br /> <br /> The mentor is in doubt what to do. He wants to be supportive of the student, but also has an obligation to the research sponsor. <br /> <br /> In addition, the student is foreign and will lose his right to stay in the country if he loses his affiliation with the university.<br /> |Important For=Mentors; Supervisors; Students with disabilities<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/mentoring/disabilities.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Respect; Accountability<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:5c0ff4eb-0a8f-4d38-a5f2-903d9dcaca05&diff=6424 2021-04-27T19:52:11Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Mentoring: time constraints |Is About=An assistant professor agreed to take on a student as thesis advisor. Over the course of the year...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Mentoring: time constraints<br /> |Is About=An assistant professor agreed to take on a student as thesis advisor. Over the course of the year it becomes clear to the assistant professor that the supervision takes more time than she expected. In addition, the student does not seem to be at the level that the assistant professor had hoped. The student also appears to make little progressin her level. The assistant professor regularly fails to read all materials for the meetings with the student. <br /> <br /> Then, a faculty colleague leaves the faculty and the assistant professor is pressured to take over one of his students. <br /> <br /> It becomes more and more clear that she cannot attend to both students. She wants to let the first student go.<br /> |Important For=Supervisors<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/mentoring/scenario6.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty; Reliability<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:6f6e3190-4355-4462-b678-28483748aeec&diff=6423 2021-04-27T19:50:54Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Mentoring: minorities |Is About=A graduate student from a minority background is studying at a good university. She struggles however du...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Mentoring: minorities<br /> |Is About=A graduate student from a minority background is studying at a good university. She struggles however due to insufficient intensive courses at her undergraduate university. Her grades are not great. <br /> <br /> A faculty member asks the sutdent to participate in meeting aimed at recruiting minority students for the university's graduate program. <br /> <br /> The student is in doubt, because on the one hand she feels flattered, but on the other hand she is afraid that her coursework will suffer.<br /> |Important For=Minorities in academia; Supervisors<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/mentoring/scenario4.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Accountability<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:79a500ad-e8ba-4cc2-9f70-e90811ec48a3&diff=6422 2021-04-27T19:49:14Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Mentoring: failure |Is About=A second-year graduate student repeatedly fails the qualifier. What should she do? |Important For=Graduate...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Mentoring: failure<br /> |Is About=A second-year graduate student repeatedly fails the qualifier. What should she do?<br /> |Important For=Graduate students<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/mentoring/scenario3.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Accountability<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Academic Freedom<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:D4f3d49c-6188-4310-9be4-dfda2f1bd40a&diff=6421 2021-04-27T19:48:10Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Mentoring: lack of interest |Is About=A graduate student is working under the supervision of a professor. However, the professor does no...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Mentoring: lack of interest<br /> |Is About=A graduate student is working under the supervision of a professor. However, the professor does not provide the student with a problem, nor seems interested in the work the student is doing alone.<br /> |Important For=Supervisors; Graduate students<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/mentoring/scenario2.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Respect<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Negligence<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:716b3f79-2637-44e5-ba81-bf459d68347a&diff=6420 2021-04-27T19:46:28Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Mentoring: expectations |Is About=A student enters graduate school with two years of funding. She easily finds a faculty member to work...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Mentoring: expectations<br /> |Is About=A student enters graduate school with two years of funding. She easily finds a faculty member to work with. After the two years, the faculty member refuses to be the student's supervisor<br /> |Important For=Supervisors; Bachelor students; Master students<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/mentoring/scenario1.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Reliability; Honesty<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:903639a3-ed85-4293-8b3c-c2ff7fb8dffc&diff=6419 2021-04-27T19:45:03Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Reaction to bias |Is About=Two post-docs, a man and a woman, are both working on new major proposals under the supervision of their pro...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Reaction to bias<br /> |Is About=Two post-docs, a man and a woman, are both working on new major proposals under the supervision of their professor. Only one of the proposals can be submitted. After much discussion, the professor selects the proposal of the female post-doc and invites the male post-doc to be co-PI with him. Being co-PI is major career opportunity. The question arises, why did the professor select the proposal of one post-doc (the female) and invite the other (the male) to be his co-PI?<br /> |Important For=Women in academia; PI's; Postdocs<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/bias/reaction.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Reliability; Honesty; Respect<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Bias; discrimination<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:4c7317e4-5b49-4c0b-a2ef-638ca0e58c31&diff=6418 2021-04-27T19:43:28Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Bias in hiring |Is About=A female physicist is applying for a prestigious job at a top university that has a reputation for being conser...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Bias in hiring<br /> |Is About=A female physicist is applying for a prestigious job at a top university that has a reputation for being conservative. During the interview the physicist is asked if she has a significant other who works in the same field. Should she answer the question?<br /> |Important For=Women in academia; Interview committees<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/bias/hiring.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty; Respect<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=bias; discrimination<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:8cad346f-42eb-4d05-b7b8-3607507bfda7&diff=6417 2021-04-27T18:42:36Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Research with human subjects |Is About=A student conducts an educational experiment on her own classmates with the permission of the pro...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Research with human subjects<br /> |Is About=A student conducts an educational experiment on her own classmates with the permission of the professor. The professor agrees the experiment has academic merit. The experiment clearly shows, one group performs significantly better than the other. <br /> <br /> The student wants to publish the results and give a talk about them. However, the student is in doubt about the right procedures.<br /> |Important For=Advisors of students; Researchers; Research Subjects; Teachers<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/human/education-research.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Respect; Accountability<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:Ec3bc473-901b-4c6f-bf8b-61dcf868c280&diff=6416 2021-04-27T18:40:33Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Hazardous materials |Is About=A PI and her students are performing a promising experiment but they experience some difficulties with the...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Hazardous materials<br /> |Is About=A PI and her students are performing a promising experiment but they experience some difficulties with the material they use. They discover that their experiment could be improved by exchanging one of their materials for another, toxic material. Should they change the material? What are the responsibilities of the PI towards her students? Do the students have any role in the decision?<br /> |Important For=Advisors of students; Teachers; Laboratory researchers<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/health/hazardous-materials.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Accountability; Respect<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Health; Responsibility<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:F036bcdd-a520-4c60-a1a6-b9701875b195&diff=6415 2021-04-27T18:38:17Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Whistle blowing |Is About=A student who has been working in a lab discovers the head of the lab is engaging in serious misconduct. The s...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Whistle blowing<br /> |Is About=A student who has been working in a lab discovers the head of the lab is engaging in serious misconduct. The student thinks she has solid evidence to demonstrate the misconduct. However, she hopes to obtain a PhD position in this lab.<br /> |Important For=PhD Students; Academic institutions<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/undergraduate/whistle-blowing.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty; Accountability<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Fabrication; Shady practices<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:C8931473-b38b-4d36-86bf-40abf91c3dc2&diff=6414 2021-04-27T18:36:11Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Reporting violations |Is About=A mentor supervises a student who takes additional courses in another department. During a google search...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Reporting violations<br /> |Is About=A mentor supervises a student who takes additional courses in another department. During a google search out of curiosity, the mentor finds out the student has plagiarised large parts of his essays for those courses.<br /> |Important For=Mentors; Supervisors<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/undergraduate/plagiarism.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Plagiarism<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:A508052c-2238-40a4-927b-783e8b732a71&diff=6413 2021-04-27T18:34:16Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Intellectual property and power imbalance |Is About=A graduate student makes a significant scientific discovery. When he shares it with...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Intellectual property and power imbalance<br /> |Is About=A graduate student makes a significant scientific discovery. When he shares it with his advisor, the advisor tells him the discovery is relatively minor. A few weeks later, the student finds out his advisor has published his discovery. The publication acknowledges the discussion with the student, but does not include him as an author. When the student confronts his advisor, she responds that &quot;this is how the world works&quot; and that he should be faster to publish his findings next time<br /> <br /> The student makes a complaint to the department chair, who asks if he has proof. The student did not takes detailed notes and fears he cannot prove the matter. He feels stupid, and doubts if he should just accept what happened.<br /> |Important For=Academic institutions; Graduate students; Advisors of students<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/data/intellectual-property.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Shady practices<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:598deeca-39f5-4311-ab2c-53124417f013&diff=6412 2021-04-27T18:32:09Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Data acquisition |Is About=A graduate student finds out there is a significant gap in the data that her research group has published on....&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Data acquisition<br /> |Is About=A graduate student finds out there is a significant gap in the data that her research group has published on. The data are unaccounted for in the lab-book.<br /> |Important For=Laboratory researchers<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/data/handling.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Honesty<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Fabrication<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:7412a1ba-c633-4782-8c95-3cfe063f9a19&diff=6411 2021-04-27T18:28:24Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Confidentiality |Is About=A researcher informally acquires knowledge of unpublished research results that support her theory. She is...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Confidentiality<br /> |Is About=A researcher informally acquires knowledge of unpublished research results that support her theory. <br /> <br /> She is invited to conference at an institution where she hopes to work. Is she allowed to share the research results which are not her own?<br /> |Important For=Researchers<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/interest/confidentiality.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Reliability; Honesty; Respect<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:12260c1e-e4dd-4be0-a355-67b7af1c3fa0&diff=6410 2021-04-27T18:22:12Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Intellectual property |Is About=A PhD graduate developed a new disk drive technology during his PhD. His inventions are patentable, and...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Intellectual property<br /> |Is About=A PhD graduate developed a new disk drive technology during his PhD. His inventions are patentable, and he and his university started the patent process. The graduate has just started his job at a new employer, a technology firm. In his first weeks, he discovers could solve an important bottleneck for his new employer. If he would reveal what he knows, he would be highly appreciated by his new employer, yet jeopardize the patent process of his old institution. There are large financial interests at stake.<br /> |Important For=PhD Students<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/interest/property.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=fictional<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Reliability; Honesty<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Conflict of Interest; patent breach; disclosing confidential information<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=Resource:38f8b3cb-1271-4be9-aa3d-220941a64b85&diff=6402 2021-04-23T15:03:12Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: Created page with &quot;{{Resource |Resource Type=Cases |Title=Pressure to disclose confidential research findings |Is About=A final year PhD is invited for an interview for a position that seems too...&quot;</p> <hr /> <div>{{Resource<br /> |Resource Type=Cases<br /> |Title=Pressure to disclose confidential research findings<br /> |Is About=A final year PhD is invited for an interview for a position that seems too good to be true. At the interview it becomes clear the chiar of the interview committee has a keen interest in the research findings of the PhD candidates research group, which are under patent, undisclosed and are is currently being submitted for publication . After the interview the chair stresses his interest in the research findings and states he is looking for &quot;team players, willing to share information with department colleagues&quot;.<br /> |Important For=Graduate and postgraduate students<br /> }}<br /> {{Link<br /> |Has Link=https://www.aps.org/programs/education/ethics/interest/findings.cfm<br /> }}<br /> {{Related To}}<br /> {{Tags<br /> |Involves=final year phd student,; interview committee<br /> |Has Timepoint=fictional<br /> |Has Location=fictional<br /> |Has Virtue And Value=Integrity; Reliability; Honesty<br /> |Has Good Practice And Misconduct=Conflict of Interest; patent breach; disclosing confidential information<br /> |Related To Research Area=PE - Physical Sciences and Engineering<br /> }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108 https://embassy.science:443/wiki-wiki/index.php?title=User:0000-0003-4410-2108&diff=6168 2021-03-22T15:07:47Z

<p>0000-0003-4410-2108: create user page</p> <hr /> <div>{{S_User | Paul | Kuyer }}</div>

0000-0003-4410-2108