View source for Report:0e24f567-642a-492f-8314-7eed0339a0bc

{{Report
|Report Type=Country Report Cards
|Title=Croatia
|Has Location=Croatia
|Research Infrastructure=The number of researchers in Croatia varies by source. The Ministry of Research and Education provided number of 23,449 registered researchers, whereas 11,481 researchers correspond to the definition of researchers introduced by the Law on Research and Higher Education <ref>1.     Kršul D. Donosimo podatke o broju znanstvenika u Hrvatskoj: Pogledajte zašto brojke variraju. Srednja hr. 2017 Oct 7. [2020 Oct 13]. Available from: 

https://www.srednja.hr/zbornica/donosimo-podatke-broju-znanstvenika-hrvatskoj-pogledajte-zasto-brojke-variraju/</ref>. According to Croatian Bureau for Statistics in 2016, 11,801 researchers (those with MS/MA or/and PhD degrees) were fully employed and 817 had contract positions <ref>Croatian Bureau of Statistics. Statistical Yearbook of the Republic of Croatia. 2017. [cited 2020 Sept 30]. Available from: https://www.dzs.hr/Hrv_Eng/ljetopis/2017/sljh2017.pdf</ref>.

Croatia has 129 higher education institutions, 105 public and 24 private; 9 public and 3 private universities, 82 institutions that are constituent units of public universities (faculties, academies and university departments), 11 public and 6 private polytechnic, 3 public and 5 private colleges <ref>Mozvag – Directory of study programmes. Selection of the institution category. [cited 2020 Dec 11]. Available from: https://www.azvo.hr/en/science/scientific-organisations</ref>. There are 70 legal entities outside the system of higher education and public research institutes that have a registered research activity – 3 institutions of special importance (National and University Library, Croatian Academy of Sciences and Arts, Lexicographic Institute “Miroslav Krleža”), hospitals and healthcare institutions with research units, 4 national institutes, archives and museums <ref>Agency for Science and Higher Education. Scientific organisations. [cited 2020 Sept 30]. Available from: https://www.azvo.hr/en/science/scientific-organisations</ref>.


{{{!}} class="wikitable sortable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed" border="1" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0" width="648"
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}'''Organisation'''
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}'''City'''
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}'''Public universities'''
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}[http://www.unios.hr/en/ Josip Juraj Strossmayer University of Osijek]
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}Osijek
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}[https://www.unipu.hr/en Juraj Dobrila Univeristy of Pula]
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}Pula
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}[https://www.unin.hr/en/ University North]
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}Koprivnica
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}[http://web.unidu.hr/index_eng.php University of Dubrovnik]
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}Dubrovnik
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}[https://uniri.hr/en/home/ University of Rijeka]
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}Rijeka
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}[https://www.unisb.hr/eng/ University of Slavonski Brod]
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}Slavonski  Brod
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}[https://www.unist.hr/en/ University of Split]
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}Split
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}[https://www.unizd.hr/eng/ University of Zadar]
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}Zadar
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}[http://www.unizg.hr/homepage/ University of Zagreb]
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}Zagreb
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}'''Private  universities'''
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}[http://www.unicath.hr/ Croatian Catholic University]
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}Zagreb
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}[https://www.libertas.hr/en/ Libertas International University]
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}Dubrovnik
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="336" valign="top"{{!}}[https://vernuni.eu/ VERN University]
{{!}} width="312" valign="top"{{!}}Zagreb
{{!}}}
|Research Funding=In 2018, the gross expenditures on research and development were 574,368,048 Croatian Kunas or €76,231,740 <ref>Republika Hrvatska, Ministarstvo financija. [cited 2020 Sept 30]. Available from: http://www.mfin.hr/adminmax/docs/Posebni%20dio%20Dr%C5%BEavnog%20prora%C4%8Duna%20Republike%20Hrvatske%20za%202018.%20godinu%20i%20projekcije%20za%202019.%20i%202020.%20godinu.pdf</ref>. Most funding was spent in the business sector (51%) <ref>1.     Kršul D. Donosimo podatke o broju znanstvenika u Hrvatskoj: Pogledajte zašto brojke variraju. Srednja hr. 2017 Oct 7. [2020 Oct 13]. Available from: 

https://www.srednja.hr/zbornica/donosimo-podatke-broju-znanstvenika-hrvatskoj-pogledajte-zasto-brojke-variraju/</ref>. In 2020, Croatia had 521 signed grants receiving €121.9 million in the EU’s H2020 program <ref name=":0">1.     H2020 Projects. [cited 2021 Feb 19]. Available from: 

https://webgate.ec.europa.eu/dashboard/sense/app/93297a69-09fd-4ef5-889f-b83c4e21d33e/sheet/erUXRa/state/analysis</ref> and 8 H2020 ERC grantee receiving €8.87 million <ref name=":0" />.
|Research Strategy=The Strategy for Education, Science and Technology of the Parliament of the Republic of Croatia from 2014 is based on a series of Croatian documents and publications on education and science and aims to propose measures aligned with the European Union’s strategies and objectives by 2025. It emphasizes that education and science can provide social stability and economic development, protect the Croatian cultural identity and place Croatia at the level of highly developed countries. One of the aims is also to develop innovative society and economy, adaptable to future challenges, and foster lifelong learning, science and innovation <ref name=":0">1.     Ministry of Science and Education. Strategy for Education, Science and Technology. 2014.

[cited 2020 Sept 30]. Available from: 

[https://mzo.gov.hr/UserDocsImages/dokumenti/Obrazovanje/Strategy%20for%20Education,%20Science%20and%20Tehnology.pdf https://mzo.gov.hr/UserDocsImages//dokumenti/Obrazovanje//Strategy%20for%20Education,%20Science%20and%20Tehnology.pdf]</ref>.

At the core of the Croatian research strategy <ref name=":0" /> are universities which play an important role in the creation and implementation of the research and educational process as well as to foster diversity, interdisciplinarity, multidisciplinarity and transdisciplinarity. Universities are expected to assume an active role in transferring knowledge and innovations economy and society and life-long learning. This aim requires strengthening the links between the universities and the private sector.
|Research Governance=Law on Research and Higher Education addresses RI <ref>Zakon o znanstvenoj djelatnosti i visokom obrazovanju. 2015. [cited 2020 Sept 30]. Available from: http://www.propisi.hr/print.php?id=5767</ref>. It was one of the first to address RI in Europe <ref>Bosch X. Integrity: Croatia's standards unusual in much of Europe. Nature.2008;454:980-982. Available from: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v454/n7204/full/454574a.html</ref>. 

National Committee for Ethics in Research and Higher Education is the highest advisory national body appointed by the Parliament of the Republic of Croatia <ref>Agency for science and higher education. Odbor za etiku u znanosti I visokom obrazovanju. [cited 2020 Sept 30]. Available from: https://www.azvo.hr/en/ethics-committee-in-science-and-higher-education</ref>. Its goal is to promote ethical principles and values in research and high education, in business and society, as well as the application of the modern technologies and protection of the environment. 

The Committee for Ethics in Research and Higher Education has oversight over the procedures and receives appeals to the decision of institutions. However, they cannot actually enforce their opinion to the institutions. They can initiate the procedure for revoking a doctoral degree, but this procedure has to be performed by the institutions. The decisions of the Committee have been published in the past, but the current law and the bylaws of the Committee are not clear on this issue. There are no recent publicly available decisions of the Committee. Institutions have ethics committees that deal with research misconduct allegations. They are not public, except when there is a media release.
{{{!}} class="wikitable sortable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed" border="1" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0" align="left"
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}'''Bodies  for RE+RI'''
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}'''Scope'''
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}[https://www.azvo.hr/en/ethics-committee-in-science-and-higher-education National  Committee for Ethics in Research and Higher Education]
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}Promotes  ethical principles and values in research and higher education.
{{!}}}
|Law And Regulation=The National Committee for Ethics in Research and Higher Education created the national Ethics Code <ref>1.     Etički kodeks Odbora za etiku u znanosti i visokom obrazovanju. 2015. [cited 2020 Sept 30]. Available from: 

https://www.azvo.hr/images/stories/tijela_agencije/Eticki_kodeks_OEZVO_pro%C4%8Di%C5%A1%C4%87eni_tekst_nakon_izmjena_i_dopuna_s_8._sjednice_15.6.15.doc</ref> which all higher education and research education institutions can, but are not obliged to implement. The Committee can initiate the procedure of revoking a doctoral degree based on its RI investigation findings. Research and higher education institutions also have their ethics codes and ethics committees which take on research integrity issues. There is rarely a separate body specific for research integrity. One of them is Croatian science foundation that has Committee for Research integrity <ref>1.     Hrvatska zaklada za znanost. Odluka. 2018 June 6. [cited 2020 Oct 13]. Available from: http://www3.hrzz.hr/UserDocsImages/dokumenti/2018/Odluke%20i%20pravilnici%202018/Odluka%20o%20Povjerenstvu%20za%20zn.%20%C4%8Destitost%20HRZZ.pdf</ref>. Croatian Digital Theses Repository also addresses Research integrity and contains codes of ethics from Croatian Universities <ref>1.     Nacionalni repozitorij završnih I diplomskih radova ZIR. Znanstvena čestitost. [cited 2020 Oct 13]. Available from: https://zir.nsk.hr/eticnost</ref>. Some associations and professional bodies also have courts of honour that deal with ethics issues, including research integrity. 
{{{!}} class="wikitable sortable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed" border="1" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0"
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}'''Law '''
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}'''Scope'''
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}[https://www.azvo.hr/images/stories/o_nama/Act_on_Scientific_Activity-UNOFFICIAL_TRANSLATION.pdf The Act on Scientific Activity and Higher  Education]
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}Stipulates the system of research  activity and higher education and indicates one of the pillars of research  activity, which is ethics of researchers.
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}[https://www.pmda.go.jp/files/000152996.pdf Ministerial Ordinance on Good Clinical Practice for  Drugs]
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}Provides standards which serve as  the Good Clinical Practice for Drugs, including the registration of clinical  trials.
{{!}}}
|Measure=<u>RI training</u>

There is no mandate for RI training but some elements of RI are a part of higher education programmes, especially at doctoral programmes and at some research-oriented studies, such as psychology or sociology (e.g. there are subjects in curriculum such as “Ethics in psychological research and practice” or “Ethical issues in sociological research”). Also, there are initiatives to introduce RI into undergraduate education, in the form of elective courses <ref>1.     University of Split School of Medicine. Why scientists cheat? [cited 2020 Oct 1]. Available from: 

http://www.mefst.unist.hr/education/courses/research-in-biomedicine-and-health/why-scientists-cheat/2450</ref>, and for PhD students, young researchers and experienced researchers as well, in the form of summer school programmes <ref>University of Split School of Medicine. Summer School on Responsible Research. [cited 2020 Oct 13]. Available from: http://www.mefst.unist.hr/studies/mefst-summer-schools/summer-school-on-responsible-research/10975</ref>. Some institutions have an official RI Advisor for doctoral students <ref>1.     University of Split School of Medicine. Research integrity advisor. [cited 2020 Oct 13]. Available from: http://www.mefst.unist.hr/studies/graduate-school/tribe/research-integrity-advisor/10971</ref> and RI checklists for supervisors and doctoral students <ref>University of Split School of Medicine. Graduate School. [cited 2020 Oct 13]. Available from: http://www.mefst.unist.hr/studies/graduate-school/131</ref>.

<u>RI dialogue and communication</u>

The public perception of research integrity in Croatia and their trust in science is low. The system is perceived as corrupt <ref>Čepo D. Političko-pravni mehanizmi sprečavanja neetičnih praksi u hrvatskoj znanosti i visokom obrazovanju: mapiranje problema i mogućih rješenja. Zagreb: Pravni fakultet Sveučilišta u Zagrebu, 2017. [cited 2020 Oct 13]. Available from: https://bib.irb.hr/datoteka/914577.2017_OZ_Neeticne-prakse-u-znanosti-i-obrazovanju.pdf</ref>. The lay press occasionally discusses the research integrity and it is usually related to cases of research fraud and academic corruption. It is not known whether there are rewards for collaborative science and incentives for networks. There have been some efforts to increase the value of research to society and reduce wasteful research. One of the examples is the Science Festival – a manifestation that has been continuously organized in Croatia since 2003 with the aim of bringing science closer to the public through information on activities and results in science, improving public perception of scientists and motivating young people to research and acquire new knowledge <ref>Festival znanosti. [cited 2020 Oct 9]. Available from: https://www.facebook.com/FestivalZnanosti</ref>. Besides that, Croatian Scientific Portal is an attempt to consolidate information on Croatian scientists, their work and scientific projects with the goal to promote and popularize science in Croatia <ref>1.     Hrvatski znanstveni portal. [cited 2020 Oct 1]. Available from:

http://www.znanstvenici.hr/index_en.php</ref>. 

<u>RI incentives</u> 

Research impact assessment and translation of research findings to the community is a part of the accreditation process for research and higher education institutions carried out by the Agency for Research and Higher Education <ref>1.     Agencija za znanost i visoko obrazovanje. Upute za sastavljanje samoanalize veleučilišta i visokih škola. 2013. [cited 2020 Oct 1]. Available from: 

https://www.azvo.hr/images/stories/vrednovanja/reakreditacija_vu/Upute%20za%20sastavljanje%20samoanalize-visoke%20%C5%A1kole-veleu%C4%8Dili%C5%A1ta%202013.doc</ref>.
{{{!}} class="wikitable sortable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed" border="1" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0"
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}'''Initiatives'''
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}'''Scope'''
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}[http://www.mefst.unist.hr/studies/mefst-summer-schools/summer-school-on-responsible-research/10975 Summer  School on Responsible Research (University of Split School of Medicine)]
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}Training
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}[https://www.azvo.hr/en/about-us/regulations/regulations Ordinance on the Content of Licence and Conditions  for Issuing Licence for Performing Higher Education Activity, Carrying Out a  Study Programme and Re-Accreditation of Higher Education Institutions]
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}Accreditation
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}[https://www.zakon.hr/z/1261/Zakon-o-hrvatskim-dr%C5%BEavnim-nagradama-za-znanost Croatian National Science Award]
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}Support
{{!}}-
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}[http://info.hazu.hr/hr/o-akademiji/znanstvena_vijeca/odbor_za_nagrade/ Croatian National Academy of Sciences and  Arts Award]
{{!}} width="376" valign="top"{{!}}Support
{{!}}}
}}